Can't Agree on a Realtor During Divorce?

A practical guide for Washington homeowners who need to make decisions about a shared home but can't agree on who should represent them.

When a couple is separating or going through a divorce, deciding what happens to the family home can be difficult enough.

But what happens when both people agree the house should be sold, yet can't agree on which real estate agent to hire?

One spouse may want to use a longtime friend or family acquaintance. The other may prefer someone recommended by their attorney. Sometimes one person has already spoken with an agent, leaving the other feeling excluded from the decision.

And sometimes the disagreement isn't really about the Realtor at all.

It may be about trust, control, money, or concern that one person's interests won't be represented fairly.

The good news is that there are practical ways to move forward without either person having to surrender their concerns.

Where do you begin?

01 / OWNERSHIP & AUTHORITY

Can one spouse choose the Realtor without the other's agreement?

Not necessarily.

In Washington, the answer depends on how the property is owned, the authority each person has, and whether there are existing agreements or court orders.

If both spouses have an ownership interest in the property, one spouse's preference for a particular Realtor doesn't automatically give that agent authority to represent both owners or complete a sale.

A real estate brokerage also needs the appropriate authorization before entering into a listing agreement.

If the divorce is already underway, an attorney can help clarify whether an existing court order addresses the sale, the selection of an agent, or the authority to make decisions.

The important distinction: Agreeing that a house should be sold and agreeing on who should handle the sale are two separate decisions.

You may have resolved the first without resolving the second.

Why agreeing on a Realtor can be so difficult

Choosing an agent is usually a straightforward business decision. During a divorce, it can take on a different meaning.

One person may be concerned that:

  • The agent is personally closer to their spouse.

  • Important information won't be shared equally.

  • Their spouse will influence the listing price or negotiations.

  • They won't be consulted before decisions are made.

  • The agent will favor a quick sale over obtaining the best reasonable price.

  • The process will create additional conflict or expense.

These concerns don't necessarily mean either person is being unreasonable.

They may simply have different expectations about what fair representation looks like.

Before debating which agent is best, it can help to identify what each person needs in order to feel comfortable with the process.

Five ways to move forward when you can't agree

1. Agree on the qualifications before discussing names

Instead of beginning with “I want to use this Realtor,” try agreeing on what the Realtor should be able to do.

For example:

  • Demonstrate experience selling homes in your local market.

  • Understand transactions involving divorce or separation.

  • Communicate important information to both owners.

  • Provide a market analysis supported by comparable sales.

  • Explain pricing, marketing, fees, and the selling process.

  • Remain professional when disagreements arise.

  • Work appropriately with both parties' attorneys when necessary.

Once the criteria are established, choosing an agent becomes less about personal loyalty and more about qualifications.

2. Consider interviewing two or three agents together

Each person could suggest an agent, with an additional candidate chosen by mutual agreement.

Ask each agent the same questions.

Questions worth asking:

  • How did you determine the recommended listing price?

  • What would you suggest doing to the property before listing?

  • How will you communicate with us if we're not speaking directly?

  • How will offers and buyer feedback be shared?

  • What happens if we disagree about a price reduction or an offer?

  • What experience do you have with divorce-related property sales?

  • How will you coordinate with our attorneys if necessary?

Pay attention not only to the answers but also to how the agent handles the conversation.

Does the agent listen to both people? Explain the reasoning behind recommendations? Avoid taking sides?

Those qualities may matter just as much as the proposed marketing plan.

3. Establish communication expectations early

One of the most common sources of conflict is the feeling that important decisions are happening without someone's knowledge.

Before signing a listing agreement, discuss how communication will work.

For example, you might agree that:

  • Both owners receive the same market updates.

  • Offers are presented to both parties promptly.

  • Pricing recommendations are provided in writing.

  • Significant decisions are documented.

  • Each person has an opportunity to ask questions.

  • Attorneys are included when legal guidance or approval is needed.

If direct communication is difficult, separate conversations may be more productive.

The goal isn't to force two people to communicate in a way that isn't working. It's to create a process where both can remain informed.

4. Separate the real estate decisions from the divorce negotiations

A Realtor can provide information about the property's condition, market value, preparation costs, likely selling expenses, and buyer activity.

But a Realtor shouldn't decide how the proceeds will be divided, interpret disputed ownership rights, or determine what either spouse is legally entitled to receive.

Those questions belong with the parties' attorneys, an appropriate mediator, or the court.

Keeping these responsibilities separate can make the real estate process easier to manage.

For example, both spouses might agree that the home should be marketed at a price supported by comparable sales, even though their attorneys are still working through how the eventual proceeds will be distributed.

Whether that arrangement is appropriate depends on the circumstances and any existing legal orders.

5. Consider mediation when discussions reach an impasse

Sometimes the disagreement has continued long enough that neither person feels comfortable making the next move.

A mediator may help the parties identify the underlying concerns, discuss possible compromises, and develop an agreement about how to select an agent.

The agreement might address:

  • How candidates will be evaluated.

  • Who will communicate with the Realtor.

  • How listing-price decisions will be made.

  • What happens if the parties disagree about an offer.

  • Which decisions require attorney involvement.

Mediation isn't appropriate in every situation, particularly where safety, coercion, or significant power imbalances are concerns. Legal guidance may be necessary before deciding how to proceed.

What if one spouse refuses to cooperate?

There is an important difference between disagreeing about an agent and refusing to participate in a sale.

If one spouse refuses to sign a listing agreement, provide access, consider offers, or cooperate with an agreed sale, the issue may require legal guidance.

Washington courts have authority to make property-division decisions in divorce proceedings, considering the circumstances of the parties and what is just and equitable.

Depending on the case, attorneys may explore negotiated agreements, temporary orders, or other court involvement.

That doesn't mean a judge will automatically select a Realtor or order an immediate sale simply because one person requests it.

If cooperation has stopped, speak with your attorney before assuming you can proceed without the other person's participation.

What if you agree on selling but disagree about the price?

This is another common point of disagreement.

One person may believe the home is worth considerably more than the other does. Sometimes that difference comes from online estimates, memories of what a neighbor's home sold for, or concerns about having enough money after the divorce.

A comparative market analysis can provide a starting point.

It should consider recent comparable sales, active competition, the home's condition, and current market conditions.

An independent appraisal may also be appropriate, particularly when valuation is disputed or needed for legal or financial purposes.

Neither a market analysis nor an appraisal guarantees what a buyer will pay.

But having independent information can shift the discussion from competing opinions toward evidence.

What if you can't even be in the same room?

You don't necessarily need to be.

When direct conversations are unproductive, much of the preliminary real estate work can be handled separately.

Each person can explain their concerns, ask questions, and review the same property information without participating in a joint meeting.

The agent can then explain which decisions require agreement, what information is still missing, and where attorney involvement may be necessary.

Separate meetings don't replace required authorizations, and they don't mean the agent can keep material transaction information from one client for the benefit of the other.

They simply provide another way to begin a difficult conversation.

What should you do before choosing an agent?

If you're at a standstill, these are reasonable first steps:

  1. Confirm the property's ownership and any existing court orders. Understand who has authority to make decisions.

  2. Identify what you've already agreed on. Is selling the home settled, or is that still being discussed?

  3. Write down your concerns about representation. Focus on what would make the process fair and workable.

  4. Agree on a few qualifications for the agent. Use those standards to evaluate candidates.

  5. Get reliable information about the property. Its condition, estimated value, mortgage balance, and selling expenses may affect the decisions ahead.

  6. Involve your attorneys when necessary. Especially if an agreement or court order is unclear.

You don't need to solve every disagreement before gathering information.

Sometimes understanding the practical choices makes the next conversation easier.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can each spouse hire a different Realtor to sell the same house?

Each spouse can seek independent real estate advice. However, having two agents independently attempt to list the same property can create conflicting obligations and practical problems. A coordinated listing arrangement generally requires appropriate authorization from the owners and agreement about brokerage representation.

Does a Realtor have to remain neutral during a divorce?

An agent's legal duties depend on whom the brokerage represents. When both spouses are clients, the agent must comply with Washington's brokerage duties to each client and cannot secretly favor one over the other. Neutrality in handling disagreements doesn't eliminate the agent's legal obligations or make the agent a legal mediator.

Can our attorneys choose the Realtor for us?

Attorneys can help negotiate an agreement about selecting an agent. Whether they have authority to make that choice for the parties depends on the agreements, authorizations, and court orders involved.

Can we sell the house before the divorce is final?

In some circumstances, yes. The parties need the appropriate authority and agreements to proceed, and any court orders must be followed. An attorney should address how the sale and proceeds fit into the divorce process.

What if one spouse wants to keep the home instead?

A buyout may be an option. It generally requires evaluating the home's value, available equity, financing, existing mortgage obligations, and the proposed property division. An attorney and lender may need to be involved.

A conversation doesn't have to begin with a listing agreement

I'm Karloc Paden, a Realtor with RE/MAX Northwest, serving Tacoma, Pierce County, and the South Sound.

My background includes more than 30 years of housing and real estate industry experience, along with training in collaborative law and conflict resolution.

When a property decision involves divorce or separation, I begin by understanding the circumstances, the people involved, and what has already been decided.

Sometimes both people are ready to sell but can't agree on representation. Sometimes one person wants to keep the home. Other times, the disagreement is about price, repairs, timing, or communication.

Those are different situations, and they don't all require the same approach.

If direct communication isn't working, we can begin with separate conversations. I can help clarify the real estate considerations while leaving legal decisions to the appropriate professionals.

You don't need to have your spouse's agreement—or even know whether you're ready to sell—to ask an initial question.

Tell me what's going on, what you've tried so far, and where things seem to be stuck.

We can start there.

Karloc (Carlos) Paden, REALTOR®

RE/MAX Northwest

Serving Tacoma, Pierce County, and the South Sound

This article provides general real estate information for Washington homeowners. It is not legal or tax advice. Divorce-related property rights, court orders, and agreements should be reviewed with a qualified Washington attorney.